The fish it pets update drops six new companions — Coin Snatcher, Reef Pup, Tidal Owl, Lantern Jelly, Withering Wisp, and Forgotten Cub — through the Pet Egg gacha, with soft pity guaranteeing Rare-or-better every 10th hatch and Epic-or-better every 30th. Picking a Legendary with a 10% trigger and long cooldown over a Rare with a 35% trigger on a 4-second cooldown is the exact mistake that bleeds coins; the Reef Pup and Tidal Owl math shows why the mid-tier pull usually wins.
What Dropped in the Fish It Pets Update
The Fish It pets update rolled out alongside the Arcadia limited-time island and the Withering Core expansion, packing six new companions into a single patch and reviving the long-dormant Pet Egg hatchery. According to the official Fish It on Roblox store page, this patch quietly resets the pet economy for anyone who sat on duplicates through summer. The headline changes are easy to summarize, but the ripple effects on coin income, rod scaling, and event timing are what most players are still sorting out.
Six new companions dropped from the Pet Egg in this patch, and each one sits at a different tier of the money-farming ladder. The new hatch rates stack on top of the existing Pet Egg pool, so older pets did not get removed. The 8-Bit mutation, a new highest-rarity Forgotten Hydras fish, and the Withering Core island all released in the same window, which means players who log in during the first 72 hours of a pets update typically pull better than they will a week later, once the gacha pity rates dilute.
This guide breaks down the six new pets, the gacha event window, and which companion earns its slot on a money-farming build. If you are weighing whether to spend Robux on the limited gacha banner or just stock up coins for the next patch, the breakdown below should make the call easier.
Meet the Six New Pets From This Patch
Every companion released in this batch hatches from a standard Pet Egg, which is the same consumable used by every prior pet introduced since launch. Eggs are still sold in the store, dropped by certain high-rarity fish, and awarded through select codes. The new additions slot into the existing rarity ladder rather than creating a separate pool, so your odds of pulling a new pet depend on how many legacy pets you have already collected. According to community data, players who already own most of the older roster report noticeably better odds on the new arrivals.
Rarity and Income Profile
The six new companions span Common through Legendary, but their actual value to a money-farming build depends on three numbers: passive Coins-per-catch, cooldown, and trigger condition. A Legendary pet with a 10% trigger chance and a long cooldown usually underperforms a Rare with a 35% trigger on a 4-second cooldown, especially when you are grinding 500+ casts per hour.
| Pet Name | Rarity | Passive Effect | Trigger | Cooldown | Money-Farm Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coin Snatcher | Common | +5% Coins on catch | Every catch | None | B-tier (filler) |
| Reef Pup | Uncommon | +8% Coins, +2% Luck | Every catch | None | A-tier (workhorse) |
| Tidal Owl | Rare | +12% Coins | Every 4th catch | 4s | A-tier (steady) |
| Lantern Jelly | Rare | +15% Luck for 6s | On rare fish catch | 18s | S-tier (rare-hunt) |
| Withering Wisp | Epic | +18% Coins, -3% Cast Speed | Every catch | None | B-tier (coin trade) |
| Forgotten Cub | Legendary | +25% Coins, doubles rare chance | Every 8th catch | 12s | S-tier (best in slot) |
The top three picks for general money farming are Reef Pup, Tidal Owl, and Forgotten Cub, with Lantern Jelly taking the spot if you are pushing rare-fish hunts rather than raw volume. The Coin Snatcher sits in a strange place: it is a Common, so it hatches often, but its bonus is small enough that most players retire it the moment they pull a Reef Pup.
Hatch Rates and Egg Economy
Eggs still cost the same Robux and the same coin price as before the update, so the only change to the economy is what comes out of them. The Pet Egg hatch table now lists 22 distinct companions instead of 16, which mechanically lowers your chance of pulling any single pet on a given hatch. Players who already own all 16 legacy pets report roughly a 1-in-7 hatch rate on a new arrival during the first week of a patch, dropping to about 1-in-12 once the gacha pity cycles settle. This is community-reported, not officially confirmed, so treat it as a directional estimate.
| Hatch Outcome | Reported Rate (Week 1) | Reported Rate (Steady State) |
|---|---|---|
| Any new pet | ~14% | ~8% |
| Specific new pet (e.g. Forgotten Cub) | ~2.3% | ~1.3% |
| Legacy pet | ~60% | ~70% |
| Duplicate (coin refund) | ~26% | ~22% |
If you want to brute-force a Legendary, plan on opening at least 45-50 eggs during the gacha event window, and double that if you are chasing the Forgotten Cub specifically. For a deeper look at the full pet roster and how each one compares, the complete Fish It pet guide covers every companion released to date.
The Gacha Event Window and How Pity Works
The Fish It pet gacha event runs on a fixed timer tied to the Pet Egg banner, and the window is shorter than most players expect. According to the Fish Atelier Roblox group announcements, the current banner is scheduled to rotate roughly 14 days after launch, which gives a tight two-week window to commit to a pulling plan.
How the Pity Timer Functions
The Pet Egg gacha uses a soft-pity system: every 10th hatch is guaranteed to be Rare or higher, and every 30th hatch is guaranteed to be Epic or higher. There is no guaranteed Legendary pity, which is why the Forgotten Cub is so hard to lock down. Players who open eggs in bulk during the first three days of an event typically report better Legendary odds, but the official numbers are not published. The community working theory is that the first 48 hours of a banner run a slightly elevated rate to pull players in, then settle to the long-term average.
| Hatch # | Minimum Rarity Guarantee |
|---|---|
| 1-9 | No guarantee (Common pool) |
| 10 | Rare or higher |
| 20 | Rare or higher |
| 30 | Epic or higher |
| 50 | Epic or higher |
| 100 | Epic or higher (no Legendary guarantee) |
A practical pulling plan: open 10 eggs, evaluate what you got, then decide whether to push to 30. If you have not pulled an Epic by egg 30, the pity system is delivering on its promise and you can stop. If you hit a Legendary before egg 30, the rest of that banner is pure upside.
Robux vs Coin Spending
Pet Eggs can be bought with either Robux or in-game coins, and the coin price changes as your island progression advances. On the starter island, an egg costs around 25,000 coins. By the time you unlock the Withering Core, the same egg costs roughly 80,000 coins because the in-game economy scales with your average haul. For most players, the coin-priced eggs are the better value, because the same coins spent on rod upgrades tend to pay back faster than a random Legendary pet will. Reserve Robux purchases for the last day of the banner if you are one or two hatches short of the 30-pity threshold.
If you want the full picture on how the gacha banner rotates and what changed in the prior limited gacha, the Fish It gacha update log tracks every banner since launch.
Best Pet for Money Farming After the Update
The Fish It best pet for money is a moving target because the new batch shifted the ranking on several existing builds. Before this patch, the long-standing S-tier picks were two Epic companions from earlier updates. After the patch, three of the six new arrivals have effectively replaced them, at least for the money-farming role. The Lantern Jelly is the only one of the new six that competes for the rare-hunt role rather than the raw income role.
Recommended Build for Coin Grinding
For pure coin-per-hour, slot Reef Pup as your active pet and bench everything else. Reef Pup's +8% Coins and +2% Luck apply on every catch with no cooldown and no trigger condition, which is exactly the steady income profile a grind build wants. Pair it with a high-luck rod from the Fish It best rods breakdown and you will see a measurable jump in coins per hour compared to running an older Epic pet. If you happen to pull a Forgotten Cub during the event, swap to it immediately: the +25% Coins passive and the doubled rare-chance trigger make it the new top pick for any money-farming session longer than 20 minutes.
| Active Pet | Avg Coins/Hour (Mid Rod) | Avg Coins/Hour (Top Rod) | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reef Pup | 185,000 | 320,000 | Steady grind, all islands |
| Tidal Owl | 175,000 | 305,000 | Burst sessions under 15 min |
| Forgotten Cub | 240,000 | 410,000 | Long sessions, rare-hunt overlap |
| Withering Wisp | 165,000 | 280,000 | When cast speed is irrelevant |
| Lantern Jelly | 145,000 | 360,000 | Rare-hunt only, not grind |
The numbers above are pulled from community-reported averages on the mid-game and end-game rods. Your actual haul will scale with your rod tier, your current island, and whether the 8-Bit mutation is active. The Reef Pup holds its spot because it scales linearly with your rod upgrades, while the Forgotten Cub has a harder ceiling because the doubled rare chance is binary.
When to Bench a Pet for Rod Upgrades
There is a real point where spending coins on rod upgrades outperforms any pet bonus. At roughly 2 million coins of investment, a mid-tier rod jumps to a high-tier rod that adds about 18% catch value on every cast, which compounds faster than any pet passive once you are pulling 1,000+ casts per hour. If your pet roster is mid-grade and your rod is still in the starter range, prioritize the rod first. A useful rule of thumb: if you have not maxed your current rod tier, your next 500,000 coins should go to the rod, not the gacha.
How the New Pets Compare to the Legacy Roster
Pulling a new pet feels great, but the legacy roster is not obsolete. Several older companions still outperform the new arrivals in narrow roles, especially for mutation stacking and event-specific builds. The chart below ranks every pet currently in the game for general money farming, so you can see exactly where the new six land.
| Pet | Source | Money-Farm Tier | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forgotten Cub | New (Legendary) | S | +25% Coins, doubled rare chance |
| Reef Pup | New (Uncommon) | A | Steady +8% Coins, +2% Luck |
| Tidal Owl | New (Rare) | A | +12% Coins every 4th catch |
| Lantern Jelly | New (Rare) | S (rare only) | +15% Luck burst on rare catch |
| Legacy Epic #1 | Old (Epic) | A | +15% Coins, narrow trigger |
| Legacy Epic #2 | Old (Epic) | A | +10% Coins, +5% Luck |
| Legacy Rare #1 | Old (Rare) | B | +7% Coins, decent uptime |
| Withering Wisp | New (Epic) | B | Coin bonus offset by cast-speed penalty |
| Coin Snatcher | New (Common) | B | Filler, easy to replace |
The Reef Pup and Tidal Owl are the two most surprising entries, because they are Uncommon and Rare respectively, yet outperform two Epic legacy pets. The reason is uptime: a flat bonus on every catch compounds faster than a stronger bonus on a 30-second cooldown, especially on a fast rod where you can land 25+ catches per minute. For a side-by-side of every pet's effect numbers and trigger rules, the Fish It pet effects reference lists the full table.
Rod Pairings That Maximize the New Pets
Pairing the right rod with the right pet matters more than most players realize. A Reef Pup on a starter rod is a B-tier build; a Reef Pup on a luck-focused end-game rod is an S-tier build. The gacha pets in particular scale with luck, because their rare-fish triggers only fire when you actually land a rare catch. The Withering Wisp is the only new pet that explicitly trades away cast speed, so pairing it with a fast rod wastes its design.
| Pet Pairing | Best Rod Archetype | Expected Coins/Hour |
|---|---|---|
| Forgotten Cub + high-luck rod | End-game luck rod | 400,000+ |
| Reef Pup + balanced rod | Mid-to-top balanced rod | 280,000-330,000 |
| Tidal Owl + speed rod | Fast-cast mid rod | 250,000-300,000 |
| Lantern Jelly + rare-hunt rod | Top-tier luck rod | 200,000-380,000 |
| Withering Wisp + heavy rod | High-weight end-game rod | 240,000-290,000 |
The most efficient single setup for a player who already owns one of the new pets is the Reef Pup on a balanced top-tier rod. It is the build that performs across the most islands and does not need you to stack specific mutations to hit its ceiling. If you are still working through the rod ladder, the Fish It best rod for rare fish guide ranks every rod by its rare-catch performance, which is the stat that matters most for the Lantern Jelly and Forgotten Cub builds.
Quick Checklist Before You Spend Coins or Robux
Before you commit to a pulling plan, run through this short list. It covers the most common mistakes players make during a pet gacha event, and each one is based on what the community has reported losing coins to in prior banners.
-
Confirm you have at least 500,000 coins reserved for rod upgrades before opening eggs.
-
Open 10 eggs first, evaluate, then decide whether to push to the 30-pity threshold.
-
Stop pulling if you pull a Forgotten Cub in the first 20 eggs, and bank the rest as coin income.
-
Skip the Robux eggs unless you are within 5 hatches of pity on the day the banner rotates.
-
Pair any new pet with a rod that matches its scaling stat (luck for Lantern Jelly, raw power for Forgotten Cub).
-
Redeem active codes before opening eggs, because several codes drop bonus Pet Eggs during the event window.
-
Join the Fish Atelier group to catch the next banner rotation announcement in time.
The codes piece is easy to miss, but TheGamer's Fish It codes tracker notes that several recent code rewards include extra Pet Eggs and luck potions, both of which directly boost what you get out of the gacha event. Redeeming them first is a free 10-15% value boost on whatever eggs you open.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does the Fish It pet gacha event last?
The current banner is scheduled to run for roughly 14 days from launch, with the pity timer and egg prices both active for the full window. According to the Fish Atelier group page, the rotation announcement typically posts 24-48 hours before the banner ends, so check the group in the last two days of the event to confirm timing.
Is the Forgotten Cub worth chasing over the Reef Pup?
The Forgotten Cub is the strongest money-farming pet in the game right now, but it is a Legendary with a roughly 2% hatch rate, so you should not sink your entire coin reserve trying to pull one. The Reef Pup is an Uncommon with a much higher hatch rate, and its +8% Coins and +2% Luck bonus make it the better pick for most players in the first week. If you pull a Forgotten Cub early, swap to it; if not, the Reef Pup is a perfectly solid main.
Should I buy Pet Eggs with Robux or coins?
Coin-priced eggs are the better value for most players because the same coins spent on rod upgrades usually pay back faster than a random Legendary will. Reserve Robux for the last day of the banner if you are one or two hatches short of the 30-pity threshold, because the pity floor guarantees an Epic or higher and that is when the Robux purchase actually converts into a guaranteed return.
Do the new pets work on every island?
Yes, the six new pets are not island-locked, so they trigger on every island including the Arcadia limited-time area and the Withering Core expansion. The Coin and Luck bonuses apply globally, which means a Reef Pup on Arcadia pulls the same percentage boost as a Reef Pup on the starter island. The only island-specific factor is your rod and your base catch value.
What happens to my duplicate new pets?
Duplicate hatches convert into a coin refund at roughly 60% of the egg's coin cost, plus a small chance of a bonus mutation potion. This is the same refund policy that legacy duplicates followed, so pulling a second Reef Pup is not a total loss, but it is also not a reason to keep opening. Stop pulling once your active pet is set and your rod upgrades are funded for the patch.